No, not this blog, the koan. Wisdom Publications recently published an anthology of short essays on Mu, the pesky little koan which I took as inspiration for Run With Mu‘s title. It’s considered by many as the foundation koan of Zen Buddhism (if you want to explore a little about koan study, try this book or this one), and it’s pretty simple, really:
A young monk asked the master, “Does a dog have Buddha nature?”
The master said, “Mu.”
“Mu” is variously translated as different variations of “no,” or “nothing,” and at least one website I’ve found says the historical meaning of Mu is roughly “the place where truth is declared,” which sounds really nice, but is it Mu? What is Mu, really? A invaluable key to personal enlightenment, or just some kind of nerdy cosmic joke?
Well, you won’t find out by reading this book, or any book. But that doesn’t mean The Book of Mu isn’t valuable for practitioners to dip into, one reading at a time, over the course of many months or years, even after you’ve moved on to focusing on other koans. I was pleased to see that an essay by my teacher is included in the book, which makes me think of the many times he and I (and the rest of my infinitely patient teachers) have wrestled together with Mu. I’ve read a few of the selections, and it’s pretty much a lot of mostly interesting variations on the same thing: “work on Mu with everything you’ve got.” Yes indeedy!
Bottom line, same as with books on running: you’re better off actually doing the work than reading about it. But that doesn’t mean you can’t realize something helpful from reading. Just don’t expect The Book of Mu, or any book, to do your work for you. While others can point you in a general direction, everyone has to find their own way through running, and running with Mu. And it’s a relief to see The Book of Mu doesn’t offer a step-by-step approach, or a program, or bulleted lists of handy dandy tips and pointers. For anyone whose practice includes koan study, it will serve as inspiration and, perhaps, something more – but no money-back guarantees. Mu doesn’t work that way.